Saturday, 23 June 2012

And the winner of x factor is...?

Genia, Pocock, Barnes, Higginbotham...or Joubert(again) Not Priestland, who looked laboured at 10, or Adam Jones, whose lack of mobility was constantly targeted by the Aussie half backs. Or Sam Warburton, who came second to David Pocock before his early departure in today's final Test. With only eleven points to separate the two sides after 240 minutes of high intensity rugby, the Welsh have some cause for satisfaction when reflecting on how far they have come under Gatland. This team will challenge the best, even away from the Millenium cauldron. But the overall feeling will be one of a missed opportunity. They let the Australians bite back in the final moments in the decisive second test, and Gatland's team will rue the lack of the killer instinct that did for the French so magnificently in the Grand Slam match. The coaching team will study the videos, perhaps reconfiguring the kick and chase game (do we need someone to do the kind of job Habanna does for the Boks, a fast hustler who may not actually make the tackle on the gathering player, but who stops him scanning all the options?) More than anything, Gatland's team will be thinking about how best to keep this team of players hungry. That, above all else, will be the decisive x factor come 2015.

Wednesday, 13 June 2012

Hot Tipuric for the top ?

 
I feel a little bit like Martin Luther hammering the 95 Theses to a church door, or perhaps the first Tory to suggest that Maggie may have lost it back at the end of the 1980's, but I'll go ahead and say it anyway. Should Justin Tipuric be starting at 7 for Wales ?
It is a measure of Capt. Sam's impact on the world rugby scene that such an opinion might be considered blasphemy, but the Ospreys flanker with the Croatian name is, quite simply, one of the best open sides around. Warburton's medical travails may just present Tipiric with a lorry load of caps anyway, but the multi-skilled flanker just keeps performing at such high levels that the Welsh selectors will have to consider this brave move if David Pocock manages to burgle as much ball as he did in the 1st Test. 

The pressure is on the Home Nations this weekend. Can Ireland prevent the series against the All blacks becoming a rout ? Can England offer an alternative to the "in yer face" approach they adopted last Saturday ? Can Capt. Sam's Wales turn the tables on Pocock and Co. ?

Ho hum. Another busy Saturday on the couch...

Monday, 28 May 2012

Casting a Long Shadow


When Shane Williams was picked to go to the World Cup in 2003, it was on the basis that he’d played a bit at scrum half, so he might be useful to have on the bench. Too small to be an out and out contender, they said. Too many tricks in his box, too likely to land his team mates in trouble in a rugbying world where risk was a dirty word. Where coaches put teams through hours of retention drills on the assumption that sooner or later the oppo would flop over the ball and give your version of Jonny his chance to have a pot at goal. Then jog back to halfway and do it all again. What you don’t want in a team with that game plan is some fly boy with happy feet. Someone who will expose you to turnovers.

Shane duly went to the World Cup, where Wales shocked the living daylights out of the All Blacks and the eventual champions, England.  The fly boy with happy feet became the idol of every vertically challenged rugby player in the world, and for a while even prop forwards stopped practising their drop goals at training to try to imitate that jagging side step.  In Wales he became one of the new breed of rugby celebs.  His talent to entertain meant that soon the media came calling, and they found that his easy style on the pitch was replicated in front of the cameras.

His ability to unlock defences made him a key member of successive Welsh sides. Usually, wingers are the great finishers, the boys with the wheels who are able to round moves off in the corner.  Shane could certainly do that, but it was his appetite for work that made him so difficult to defend against. Look at his two “last” tries. Against the Wallabies in the Autumn, and again last night against Leinster, he drifted off his wing, and scanned the defence in front of him. Then there was a call, a swerve, and he skipped past despairing dives.

But don’t let this easy charm fool you. Shane is no enthusiastic amateur who just made it because he was an outrageous talent. He is also one of the great professionals, a player who knew he had to work hard in order to make it at the highest level, who had to learn to be more than the fly boy with the happy feet. That makes him a great role model for all those who play the game. He reminds the coach of the dangers of restricted thinking, he reminds players young and old that there is always something you can do to be a better player. Most of all, he reminds the spectator of why they love this stupid, rule ridden game in the first place – to see talented players do things you could only dream of doing…

Saturday, 19 May 2012

Just too good


Thoroughbreds from the RDS canter on.

Having patched up O’Driscoll and beaten Clermont in one of the most impressive Heineken matches of another great year, there was no earthly way that Leinster would get beaten. Having said that, the rugged Ulstermen had managed to negotiate this year’s “Group of Death” – which is usually the one without an Italian side in it – murdering Leicester 47-0 in the process, then went and won at Thomond Park in the quarter finals. 

The very idea that it could be Ulster’s year was kicked into touch early on, courtesy of that man O’Driscoll, who executed one of his trademark offloads. The muscular certainties that Sean O’Brien brings to a rugby field did the rest. I still have question marks over young Sean as a 7 – O’Driscoll and D’Arcy’s excellence at the breakdown mask his shortcomings when quick thoughts and deeds are needed in the tackle area – but he is one hell of a ball carrier. And I would never, ever, pick a fight with him. Just ask the redoubtable Ulster back row, who tried to subdue the Leinsterman all afternoon, but left the field of play exhausted. Ferris, one of the players of the tournament,  came off second best here.

The vital cog in the Ulster machine, Ruan Pienaar, had an average game. He lacked authority, perhaps finding too much on his shoulders with the 20yr old Paddy Jackson at 10. When Pienaar did try to utilise his kicking game, he was just setting Kearney up for another virtuoso high catch. Even when the Ulstermen managed to breach the blue wall, the clock was ticking on, and they had nothing left.

So it’s 3 out of 4 for Leinster. And that ain’t bad…

Monday, 30 April 2012

Peerless Pienaar kicks Ulster all the way to Twickenham


The neutral may well be rooting for Brian and the Leinster boys come Heineken final day, if the semi final displays give us any clues as to the likely entertainment factor. Despite the fact that Ulster will be travelling across the Irish Sea as underdogs, the average rugby fan will probably feel that Heaslip, Sexton, and  O’Driscoll  offer rather more pazzazz than an Ulster side built around Wannenburg, Muller and Pienaar. As in 1999, when they won this competition, they have a grinding, remorseless pack of forwards allied to a strong kicking game. Like Saracens, they have chosen to import some hard nosed Boks into the set up to play the physical, territorial game that wins the tight matches. All this has been a carefully considered strategy. Not many internationals here to distract the focus, just some key personnel with the experience to handle the big occasions – Best, Wallace from “home”, and the key acquisition of Pienaar to direct the forwards, set the tempo for the backs, and kick goals from just about anywhere. And a look at the Celtic league standings will show that this is a team built for the sharp end of the Heineken Cup.

In short, they are a tough, uncompromising outfit, a nightmare to play against. Brian and the boys will be hoping this wet spell of weather is out of the way to give them a dry track at HQ. But they would be foolish to think that a meeting with Pienaar and his pals will be a warm hearted Irish craic of a day.

Wednesday, 25 April 2012

Big Phil to fill the Blues gap ?


Cash rich French teams continue to circle over the corpse that is the Cardiff Blues squad, determined to take the opportunity to strip the Grand Old Dame of Welsh club rugby of its juicy morsels. Alex Cuthbert gave a gloriously non committal reply to the inevitable question after his man of the match winning performance against Edinburgh, so we can assume he’s on his velo, too. Bon voyage, and Welsh fans will truly wish him all the best. In such an uncertain world, playing a game that is made up of potentially career ending collisions, we can hardly blame him. But will he get enough game time at a place like Toulon to learn his trade ? Hardly a concern for an old stager like Gethin Jenkins – indeed, careful management of game time is just what a 30+ prop needs – but a young player like Cuthbert needs game time He needs time reading games, needs time (in his case particularly) under the high ball, chasing back, covering kicks.

News that Big Phil Davies, one of the most highly regarded coaches either side of Offa’s Dyke, is in the frame for the vacant Blues job has to be good news for Welsh rugby. Although I don’t share the sense of doom and gloom that accompanies the big money signings, it has to be acknowledged that the National set up needs a strong Regional scene. The success of Gatland and Edwards has to a large extent hinged on the Regions being able to expose young players to a good playing environment.  Big Phil’s reputation may do a great deal to keep the Blues squad looking forward.

With “foreign” stars moving on, the Blues are looking closer home for replacements – Jason Tovey from the Dragons is a sensible piece of business, for example. Money is clearly tight. The move to the Arms Park – yet to be confirmed, but obviously on the cards – would also make sense. The players can’t be happy playing in front of vast empty stands as they are at the City Stadium. They can always return there when the big Heineken games demand it.

The job now is to ensure that the Blues – and the other Welsh regions – get to play those big games often enough.

Tuesday, 10 April 2012

What will life be like with these Lions ?

Good question, Mr Gatland. I expect you know the core of your side already. Most would expect it to be formed of your own Welsh players, so no surprises...perhaps.
Gatland is no rosey eyed loyalist. The strong foundations he has built in this Welsh squad have been based on a lack of such emotion. Players who failed to perform heard it in no uncertain terms. Ryan Jones, one of the players of the 2012 6 Nations, had to bounce back from being stripped of the captaincy, then seeing that young buck Faletau emerge from relative obscurity to become Wales' bolt on starting No 8. The canny Kiwi coach will also remember some of the Lions lessons of the past. Most painfully, Woodward learned that attempting to reassemble the 2003 WC winners in Lion skins was doomed to failure.
The starting Welsh XV may well form the core of the Gatland Lions pride, but some of those big names will need to look over their shoulders. Can any coach afford to leave such players as Heaslip, Ferris, Best, O'Brien, Sexton and Kearney of Ireland on the touchlines ? Foden, Tuilagi and Croft ?

For what it's worth, at this ridiculously early stage, here goes my Lions starting XV - Jenkins, Best, Jones, Gray, Charteris, Lydiate, Warburton (c), Heaslip, Phillips, Sexton, Roberts, Tuilagi, North, Halfpenny, Kearney.
Croft for Gray, O'Brien for Lydiate, Foden for Kearney, Healy for Jenkins after 60 mins.